•  
      request #40100 Pull Request comment is empty after scrolling
    Infos
    #40100
    Cyndie Martin (cmartin)
    2025-01-15 16:30
    2024-10-24 14:54
    41771
    Details
    Pull Request comment is empty after scrolling

    How to reproduce :

    • Go to Git service, in a git repository that has an open Pull Request
    • Click on Pull Request tab,
    • Then select the Pull request among the PR list.
    • Click on the Changements tab
    • Choose a file that has changed in the PR (prefer a file with a lot of changes : you will need to scroll down)
    • At the first change, click on the line number to add a comment
    • Write a comment but do not Submit (cf. image)
    • Scroll down to the other changes in the file until you will no more see the previous comment area
    • Scroll up

    Result : The comment area is empty

    Expected : The previously edited comment (but non validated) is displayed as it was left before the scroll

    Sometimes a comment has been long to write and user need to see another part of the file before validating his comment. And it can be frustrating to loose the comment in this case. Wich lead to a lack of confidence in the Tuleap tool.

    If it can help, we notice that this behavior happens for Diff unifié, and in the right column of Diff côte à côte. This behavior doesn't happen in the left column of Diff côte à côte.

    Pull Request
    15.13
    EL9 (RockyLinux|AlmaLinux|RHEL)
    • [ ] enhancement
    • [ ] internal improvement
    Jean-Marie Henaff (jmhenaff), Alex Newcomb (anewcomb_sf)
    Stage
    Empty
    Closed
    2025-01-15
    Attachments
    References

    Follow-ups

    User avatar

    Raah, I updated the wrong ticket. I re-open this one. sorry for the noise.


    • Status changed from Closed to Reopen
    • Close date cleared
    User avatar
    Martin GOYOT (goyotm)2025-01-07 14:25
    • Is an Enhancement or an internal improvement? cleared values: enhancement
    User avatar
    Cyndie Martin (cmartin)2024-10-24 14:54
    • Original Submission
      Something went wrong, the follow up content couldn't be loaded
      Only formatting have been changed, you should switch to markup to see the changes