Skip to main content

Public

Project privacy set to public. By default, its content is available to everyone (authenticated or not). Please note that more restrictive permissions might exist on some items.

    •  
      request #11184 Give the same name two diferente page
    Actions
    Infos
    #11184
    Sandra Madruga (smadruga)
    2018-02-28 11:29
    2018-02-23 15:21
    11524
    Details
    Give the same name two diferente page
    I don’t know if this is the correct way to inform you of a bug I detected in Tuleap 9.17.

    We us a lot the plugin “Mediawiki”, and when we give the same name to a page that already exist, information of the old page disappears.

    With this bug we lost lots of informations .

    I hope in the next release this bug is resolved.
    Mediawiki
    9.17
    Empty
    • [ ] enhancement
    • [ ] internal improvement
    Empty
    Stage
    Empty
    Declined
    2018-02-28
    Attachments
    By Sandra Madruga (smadruga)
    (56 kB)
    img1.JPG
    By Sandra Madruga (smadruga)
    (30 kB)
    img2.JPG
    By Sandra Madruga (smadruga)
    (23 kB)
    img3.JPG
    References
    References list is empty
    Display settings

    Follow-ups

    User avatar
    Manuel Vacelet (vaceletm)2018-02-28 11:29

    Actually you never loose information as it's always present in page history.

    Plus, we don't maintain Mediawiki ourselves, it's an integration of the upstream software. If you want the behaviour to be updated, you should contact them.

    Thanks.

    User avatar
    Sandra Madruga (smadruga)2018-02-28 11:08
    You can declined this issue.
    But with this problem you should have at least a popup that indicate you are creating a page with the same name.

    With this bug I have lost lots of information.

    Thanks in advace.
    User avatar
    Manuel Vacelet (vaceletm)2018-02-28 10:53

    It's the expected behaviour of mediawiki (and actually all wiki system).

    [[Odoo 9]] will resolve to the same page whereever you write it in your MW.

    If you want different pages, you must set different names, please check mediawiki documentation for that.

    • Status changed from New to Declined
    • Close date set to 2018-02-28
    User avatar
    Sandra Madruga (smadruga)2018-02-28 10:48
    Hello,

    Correct the page is the same. This is the problem.
    I should have 2 pages. One linked to Odoo 9 and the other one link to Odoo 10.
    Because the path is diferente.

    The problema is we have severals version of Odoo and we give the same names to the pages.
    User avatar
    Thomas Gerbet (tgerbet)2018-02-28 10:13
    Hello,

    I tried to reproduce your issue with your example but the links I create in the "Odoo 9" and "Odoo 10" pages link to the same page (and the content is the same).
    User avatar
    Sandra Madruga (smadruga)2018-02-23 16:59
    and the page "Sup odoo", I have the info we need.

    And if I do the same path for Odoo 10, the page "sup odoo" the will have the same name of the Odoo 9, will desapear with the information.
    and the latest page what is created, will keep the information.
    User avatar
    Manuel Vacelet (vaceletm)2018-02-23 16:41

    It's very hard to understand what you are trying to do.

    Could you give me the exact name of the page and the exact wiki content you created ?

    User avatar
    Sandra Madruga (smadruga)2018-02-23 16:24
    last edited by: Sandra Madruga (smadruga) 2018-02-23 16:39
    Hello Manuel,
    I'm sorry, but I did not explain it correctly.
    Within the same mediawiki,
    page Odoo 9 -> page "support info"
    Page Odoo 10 -> "support info"
    mediawiki
    * Odoo 9
    support info
    * Odoo 10
    support info
    with is the structure.
    thanks.

    _________________________________________

    [root@alm ~]# tuleap -v
    9.17
    User avatar
    Manuel Vacelet (vaceletm)2018-02-23 16:04

    I cannot reproduce your problem.

    I just created 2 Mediawiki pages names "Option A" in 2 different projects and I can see both different contents without any issues.

    What version of Tuleap are you running exactly (you can have the information running ./tuleap -v on the server)

    User avatar
    Sandra Madruga (smadruga)2018-02-23 15:37
    last edited by: Sandra Madruga (smadruga) 2018-02-23 15:50
    Hello,
    So, what I did was, in wikimedia I created a "Support" page and on the Support page, I created a new link to a new page called "Option A" with various information.
    Then, a few days later, I create a new page in a different project with the name "Option A". The first page "Option A" disappeared with all the information I have.
    So I can not have 2 folders or page with the same name.
    I hope you've been able to explain.

    Thanks in advance.